The Merits and Drawbacks of Using Low-Dk Laminates in High-speed PCBs

Watch Lee Ritchey of Speeding Edge as he discusses using low-Dk materials in high-speed digital designs.

The merits of using low DK (dielectric constant) laminates in PCBs that have very high data rate paths:

  • For a given trace width selected to produce a given impedance, the laminate used between the trace and its adjacent plane can be thinner. This results in an overall thinner PCB.
  • For a given thickness of laminate used to produce a given impedance, with a lower Dk laminate the trace width can be wider resulting in a lower signal loss due to skin effect loss in the trace.
  • For larger, high layer count backplanes, using a lower Dk laminate can reduce overall board thickness.

The drawbacks of using low Dk laminates:

  • Lower Dk laminates cost more and provide less flexibility in terms of material choices. In some instances, using a lower Dk laminate will create a situation wherein the material used is only available as a single-source.
  • In terms of loss vs trace width, a much greater improvement in loss is achieved by using a lower loss laminate than by increasing trace width.  Also, increasing trace width increases over board thickness. Example: a 22-layer board with 4 mil wide stripline traces produces a board that is 106 mils thick. Increasing the stripline traces to 8 mil wide produces a board that is 160 mils thick—a  60% increase in overall board thickness.

Conclusions: increasing trace widths does not provide enough of a benefit in loss to warrant the use of a low Dk laminate. Use of a lower loss laminate, such as Isola’s Tachyon, yields a much better improvement in terms of loss.  In addition, there is 60% less material used which can pay for the added cost of a lower loss laminate.

14 January 2015

Related Posts

Video Time To Delamination
Video: Time to Delamination
Separation of the internal layers of a laminate or printed wiring board is commonly referred to as delamination. Caused by internal stress when the sample is exposed to heat, delamination results in a change in the sample dimension measurable by a Thermomechanical Anaylzer or TMA. Time to delamination is…
Isola To Exhibit At Productronica 2013
Isola to Exhibit at productronica 2013
Isola to Exhibit at productronica 2013 Attendees will learn about the latest innovations in laminates for multilayer printed circuit boards. CHANDLER, Ariz., October 17, 2013 — Isola Group S.a.r.l., a market leader in copper-clad laminates and dielectric prepreg materials used to manufacture multilayer Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs), will exhibit at…
Video Dynamic Mechanical Analysis Isola
Video: Dynamic Mechanical Analysis
  Dynamic Mechanical Analysis or DMA measures the storage and loss modulus and Tan Delta of a material. Storage or elastic modulus is a material’s ability to store energy applied to it for future use or to spring back when deformed. Loss modulus is a material’s ability to dissipate energy…